Blog
Commerce media: Build vs. buy in the age of AI
By Sarah Wheeler
AI is fundamentally changing the economics of software development, so for companies launching or expanding a commerce media network, that changes the traditional build-versus-buy calculation.
Historically, the decision often came down to speed, cost, and control. Building internally offered greater customization but required more engineering resources, whereas buying an established platform accelerated time to market, often with tradeoffs in flexibility.
As AI reduces development time, those tradeoffs are shifting. The ability to build an application is becoming less of a competitive advantage. The ability to operate sophisticated advertising infrastructure, make intelligent decisions in real time, and continuously optimize commercial outcomes remains much harder to replicate.
This article helps evaluate the tradeoffs so you can accelerate both your deployment and continuous launches of new functionality to stand out to advertisers in your market. As you build, leverage Koddi’s new guide, published with Wiley: Building Commerce Media Networks: Scale and Future-Proof Your Network.
Should you build or buy commerce media technology?
In short: it depends on what you’re building.
AI has made it increasingly practical for organizations to develop their own applications, interfaces, integrations, and business-specific workflows. But building software and operating advertising infrastructure are two different investments.
Commerce media networks must coordinate complex decisions across inventory, audiences, advertisers, channels, and transactions. They need technology that performs reliably, supports business-specific rules, and continues improving as the network scales.
Organizations have three primary options:
- Build internally: Develop and maintain advertising technology with internal engineering resources, retaining control over the architecture and roadmap.
- Buy an established platform: Access specialized infrastructure, automation, integrations, and ongoing product development through a technology provider.
- Combine internal and external technology: Build the capabilities that differentiate the business while relying on established infrastructure for specialized advertising functions.
The right model depends on the organization’s commercial objectives, technical capabilities, and long-term growth plans.
What technology does a commerce media network need?
Commerce media technology supports the advertising process from campaign planning and activation through optimization and measurement.
Core capabilities include:
- Ad serving: Selecting and delivering advertising across eligible inventory.
- Campaign management: Managing advertisers, budgets, targeting, creative, and delivery.
- Optimization and decisioning: Improving relevance, pacing, pricing, yield, and advertising performance.
- Audience management: Activating permitted first-party signals to create relevant audiences.
- Demand integrations: Connecting advertisers and buying platforms across channels.
- Analytics and measurement: Connecting advertising activity to business outcomes.
- Governance: Managing permissions, data access, advertising policies, and auditability.
AI can accelerate the development of interfaces and workflows around these capabilities. But the infrastructure behind them must still make decisions within strict latency requirements, process large volumes of data, maintain reliable integrations, and continuously improve performance.
These systems also need to work together. A network may have a capable ad server but struggle to scale if campaign management requires extensive manual work, data sits across disconnected systems, or measurement cannot connect advertising to transactions.
As AI agents take on more advertising operations, connected infrastructure becomes even more important. Agents need reliable data and systems capable of executing authorized actions across the advertising business.
Option 1: Building commerce media technology internally
Building internally gives organizations direct control over development priorities, architecture, and capabilities. AI is making this approach more accessible by accelerating coding, testing, and application development.
Advantages of building
- Control and customization: Internal teams can tailor technology to their specific inventory, customer experiences, and commercial requirements.
- Faster development with AI: AI-assisted engineering can reduce the resources needed to create interfaces, workflows, and certain technical components.
- Ownership of proprietary capabilities: Organizations can retain control over technology that directly contributes to their competitive differentiation.
Challenges of building
- Specialized infrastructure requirements: Real-time auctions, predictive optimization, attribution, and advertising integrations demand expertise beyond conventional software development.
- Ongoing maintenance: Internal teams are responsible for reliability, security, integrations, and performance as requirements evolve.
- Time to proven performance: Developing a functional system may be relatively fast. Validating its performance and operating it reliably at scale can take considerably longer.
- Competing priorities: Engineering resources dedicated to advertising infrastructure may be unavailable for initiatives closer to the company’s core commerce business.
Building can make sense when a capability creates meaningful competitive advantage and the organization has the expertise to maintain and advance it.
The distinction is between the cost of developing technology and the total cost of owning it.
Option 2: Buying an established commerce media platform
Buying commerce media technology means working with a provider that offers infrastructure designed to support advertising operations.
As AI accelerates software development, faster implementation becomes a less compelling advantage on its own. The greater value of an established platform lies in the specialized infrastructure, intelligence, integrations, and operational experience that would otherwise need to be developed internally.
Advantages of buying
- Proven infrastructure: Established platforms provide systems designed for real-time decisioning, campaign delivery, optimization, and measurement at scale.
- Specialized intelligence: Technology providers can continuously invest in predictive bidding, relevance, pricing, audience targeting, and yield optimization.
- Existing integrations: Connections to demand sources, buying platforms, and measurement partners can accelerate network expansion.
- Continuous innovation: Operators gain access to new capabilities without independently developing and maintaining every advancement.
- Operational efficiency: Connected systems and automation can help teams manage larger advertising programs without proportional increases in headcount.
Challenges of buying
- Control and flexibility: Operators need to understand how much they can customize independently and whether the platform supports their business model.
- Integration requirements: The technology must connect with existing commerce systems, customer data, and workflows.
- Long-term dependency: Restrictions on data portability, business rules, or development flexibility can become limitations as the network evolves.
Buying technology should not require surrendering control of the media business. Operators should retain authority over customer data, inventory, pricing, prioritization, advertiser relationships, and commercial strategy.
Option 3: Combining internal and external technology
For many businesses, a hybrid approach provides a practical balance between differentiation and specialized infrastructure.
As AI reduces application development costs, operators have more opportunities to build their own advertiser experiences, internal tools, and AI-driven workflows without rebuilding the entire advertising stack.
For example, a network might develop a proprietary advertiser interface while relying on an external platform for ad serving, real-time auctions, optimization, and measurement.
This allows the organization to retain ownership of its customer relationships, commerce data, inventory, and commercial decisions while accessing proven advertising infrastructure.
The key is interoperability. Well-documented APIs, accessible data, and configurable business rules allow operators to innovate on top of their infrastructure. Without those foundations, hybrid architectures can create disconnected systems and additional operational complexity.
Commerce media build vs. buy: Key considerations
AI changes the economics of software development, but the long-term costs of maintaining infrastructure and improving performance remain important.
| Consideration | Build internally | Buy a platform | Hybrid approach |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time to market | AI accelerates development; production readiness varies | Established capabilities can accelerate deployment | Depends on development and integration requirements |
| Engineering investment | Internal development and infrastructure ownership | Less core development required | Focused on differentiated capabilities |
| Customization | Direct architectural control | Depends on platform flexibility | Custom experiences on shared infrastructure |
| Maintenance | Internal responsibility | Primarily provider-managed | Divided by system ownership |
| Intelligence and optimization | Requires internal models and ongoing improvement | Access to specialized optimization | Provider intelligence plus proprietary business signals |
| Integrations | Developed and maintained internally | May include established connections | Requires reliable APIs and interoperability |
| Long-term flexibility | Depends on architecture and resources | Depends on provider capabilities | Depends on integration and ownership boundaries |
The lowest initial development cost does not necessarily produce the lowest total cost of ownership. Networks should consider the engineering, operational, and commercial investments required as the business grows.
What should you look for in a commerce media technology partner?
As AI makes individual software capabilities easier to build, technology providers need to demonstrate value beyond feature availability.
Key questions include:
- Can the platform support your business model? Evaluate its flexibility across inventory, customer journeys, advertiser types, commercial rules, and channels.
- Does the infrastructure deliver measurable performance advantages? Look for demonstrated improvements in yield, budget utilization, advertising performance, decisioning speed, and operational efficiency.
- Can you build on top of it? Open APIs, accessible data, and configurable workflows should support proprietary applications and future development.
- How well are the capabilities connected? Ad serving, optimization, campaign management, audiences, and measurement should work together without unnecessary manual processes.
- What control do you retain? Understand ownership of data, inventory, pricing, prioritization, measurement, and advertiser relationships.
- Can the platform support new channels and demand sources? Evaluate existing integrations and the provider’s ability to support future expansion.
- Is AI embedded in the underlying technology? Look beyond conversational interfaces to production capabilities that improve relevance, forecasting, bidding, pricing, and optimization.
- Is the infrastructure agent-ready? Determine whether AI agents can securely access data, interact with connected systems, and execute authorized actions.
- How does the technology perform at scale? Evaluate decisioning latency, reporting reliability, data processing, and system performance under realistic workloads.
- How quickly is the partner innovating? Consider its record of improving infrastructure, introducing capabilities, and delivering measurable results.
A strong technology partner should help a network improve its current business while supporting its ability to build and innovate independently.
Think beyond the initial launch
A common mistake in build-versus-buy decisions is optimizing for the first advertising product without considering what comes next.
A network may launch with sponsored listings before expanding into display, video, offsite activation, self-service, programmatic demand, or AI-driven advertising experiences.
Each new capability introduces requirements for campaign management, inventory coordination, optimization, and measurement.
AI may accelerate development, but the underlying infrastructure must support those capabilities together. This becomes particularly important as agents begin planning campaigns, optimizing budgets, and executing advertising workflows across channels.
The objective is to establish a technology foundation that can evolve without requiring the business to repeatedly rebuild its core systems.
Build the capabilities that differentiate your network
AI is giving commerce media networks more freedom to develop their own technology. The opportunity is to direct that development capacity toward the capabilities that create the greatest competitive advantage.
For most commerce businesses, that advantage begins with customer relationships, first-party data, inventory, and an understanding of the customer journey.
Turning those assets into a scalable advertising business requires infrastructure capable of making intelligent decisions, optimizing performance, connecting demand, and measuring outcomes.
As software becomes easier to build, the value of the infrastructure powering it becomes increasingly important.
Whether you build internally, buy an established platform, or combine both approaches, prioritize the capabilities that make your business unique and the technology foundation that will help them perform.
For a deeper look at commerce media infrastructure, AI, automation, and operating models, download Building Commerce Media Networks by Koddi, a Wiley custom publication.
GET IN TOUCH
Ready to get started?
Don’t let your brand get lost in the noise. Partner with Koddi to unlock the power of commerce media and transform the way you engage with your customers. Our team of experts is here to help you navigate complexities and develop a strategy that drives results — no matter what industry – in as little as 45 days.